NPR’s Scott Detrow talks with Adam Jentleson, a Democratic strategist and the founder and president of the liberal assume tank the Searchlight Institute, about the place Graham Platner goes from right here.
Transcript
SCOTT DETROW, HOST:
Graham Platner was as soon as seen as the important thing to Democrats flipping sufficient seats to retake the U.S. Senate. Now, Democratic Occasion leaders are withdrawing their endorsements and calling for him to drop out of the Senate race in Maine. Yesterday, Politico reported {that a} girl he as soon as dated accused him of sexual assault. Platner denied the accusation and stated, quote, “any accusation of nonconsensual conduct is categorically unfaithful.” However this information got here after different studies of unsettling conduct from ladies who beforehand dated Platner and an extramarital sexting scandal. So the place does the race go from right here? For that, we referred to as Adam Jentleson. He is a Democratic strategist and the founder and president of the Searchlight Institute, a liberal assume tank. Thanks for coming by, Adam.
ADAM JENTLESON: Thanks for having me.
DETROW: Is that this marketing campaign viable anymore?
JENTLESON: No, it is completely not. I am stunned Platner hasn’t dropped out already. Perhaps he drops out by the point this section is over. However he is gone, and, you realize, the earlier, the higher so – as a result of Maine Democratic Occasion guidelines do permit the occasion to pick out a substitute so long as he drops out earlier than Monday. So the clock is ticking. I feel, you realize, Democrats nonetheless have a fantastic probability to win this seat if he drops out, so, you realize, he ought to get out sooner somewhat than later.
DETROW: Platner had quite a lot of assist from Democratic voters, even amid all these different scandals. What to you is the least horrible strategy to rapidly select a brand new nominee who the voters did not get behind?
JENTLESON: I feel you must work out a declare to legitimacy for this new nominee. , we noticed how, you realize, not truly being elected by voters dogged Kamala Harris because the nominee when she was picked by, you realize, basically occasion insiders to be the nominee. , she was vp, however she was – she didn’t win the Democratic nomination within the conventional manner. So I feel you bought to use the identical commonplace right here. , there have been seven Democratic candidates who ran for 2 statewide slots a few month in the past within the main, proper? There was the race for senator, and there is the race for governor.
DETROW: Yeah.
JENTLESON: In these seven candidates, there are quite a lot of credible nominees, all of whom, I feel, would have a stable probability at beating Susan Collins. The one one who cannot is Platner himself. , and all of them would have some declare to legitimacy as a result of lots of people solid their votes for them. I feel, you realize, holding a conference that you must plan in lower than a month after which, you realize, crafting guidelines and bylaws that everyone agrees to, you possibly can make it work, however it’s – you realize, if you happen to use subjective requirements to decide on the nominee at that conference, I feel you are going to run into quite a lot of bother and also you run an actual danger of leaving the occasion divided, which might be an actual catastrophe as we head into the overall election towards Susan Collins.
DETROW: Nicely, that is what I wish to ask about as a result of an enormous a part of Platner’s energy was that he was not an institution determine. He didn’t come up in politics in any manner in any respect, and that basically appealed to voters in a manner that we have seen in a bunch of states proper now. I imply, how do you get these individuals who supported Platner to be on board with a mainstream politician who’s chosen a method or one other via a really fast course of that is not as open as an everyday main?
JENTLESON: Nicely, I feel there’s danger in overstating that case, to be sincere with you. I feel, you realize, the first that Maine had a month in the past was form of a cut up display, proper? As a result of, you realize, on the Senate aspect, you had folks casting their vote for Platner, who, as you say, is an antiestablishment politician. However on the governor aspect, on the identical day, these voters went to the polls and elected Chellie Pingree, who’s – or, excuse me, Hannah Pingree, the daughter of Chellie Pingree, who’s, you realize, an institution politician. , she’s great. I feel she’s going to be a fantastic governor, and I feel she’s bought a fantastic probability to win, you realize? However she wasn’t an antiestablishment candidate, you realize?
And whenever you have a look at the votes, you realize, about 156,000 Mainers solid their votes for Graham Platner, you realize? And the man who’s form of positioned because the antiestablishment candidate, you realize, who Graham is attempting to, you realize, railroad via as his substitute, Troy Jackson, solely bought about, you realize, 45,000 votes. So 100,000 Mainers voted for Graham Platner however then supported both Hannah Pingree or Nirav Shah, as properly.
DETROW: Adam, let me…
JENTLESON: So quite a lot of those self same individuals who voted for him additionally supported a number of the extra estabishment politicians.
DETROW: I wish to be sure that we’ve got time for yet another thorny query with all of this. I am questioning if you happen to assume the Democratic Occasion, the occasion that embraced MeToo, that talked about believing ladies, do you assume it misplaced credibility or ethical authority by sticking with Platner via the entire scandals main as much as this second?
JENTLESON: Not in the event that they eliminate him. I feel, you realize, one of many issues the Republicans did is after they have been confronted with these questions, they caught with them. They caught with Trump. They caught with Matt Gaetz. They caught with any variety of nominees after realizing deeply immoral issues about them. So so long as we maintain enterprise right here and substitute him with anyone we will all get behind, I feel we will maintain our heads excessive.
DETROW: And in 30 seconds or much less, you continue to assume Susan Collins is beatable?
JENTLESON: I completely do. , it is a very favorable nationwide atmosphere for Democrats. Trump’s numbers are horrible. Susan Collins has been, you realize, a die-hard supporter of Trump again and again. She’s misplaced her unbiased streak. , we simply must get anyone on this race who can simply, you realize, be regular and, you realize, make the case and prosecute the case towards Susan Collins. And in that case, I feel this seat remains to be very winnable.
DETROW: Put be regular on a bumper sticker. That’s Adam Jentleson, Democratic strategist, founding father of Searchlight Institute assume tank. Thanks a lot.
JENTLESON: Thanks.
Copyright © 2026 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts might differ. Transcript textual content could also be revised to right errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its authentic broadcast or publication. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.
