[Pinoy Criminology] Defending the outdated and sickly from extended trial detention

There are moments when a authorized system should pause and ask itself a fundamental, uncomfortable query: At what level does detention cease being justice and begin turning into a gradual loss of life sentence?

That query hovered over the not too long ago concluded Jail and Jail Decongestion Summit organized by the Philippine Supreme Court docket from January 21 to 23, 2026, on the Manila Resort. Amid discussions of clogged dockets, delayed hearings, and overworked judges, one proposal stood out for its ethical readability and sensible urgency: medical recognizance.

Medical recognizance is disarmingly easy. It permits the provisional launch of an individual disadvantaged of liberty whose well being has deteriorated to the purpose that continued detention will irritate sickness or end in loss of life. It isn’t acquittal. It isn’t absolution. It’s a recognition that the State’s energy to detain doesn’t embody the facility to let individuals die needlessly whereas ready for his or her day in court docket.

This proposal arises from a actuality too grim to disregard. Philippine jails, notably these beneath the Bureau of Jail Administration and Penology (BJMP), function at a mean congestion price of 286 % nationwide, inserting the nation among the many most congested jail methods on the planet. Cells constructed for 20 individuals routinely maintain three or 4 instances that quantity. In excessive circumstances documented in recent times, amenities designed for a handful of detainees have held lots of. These should not outliers; they’re signs of a system stretched far past humane limits.

Congestion would already be insupportable if detention had been temporary. However it isn’t. Prison circumstances within the Philippines take a mean of 528 days to be resolved. That could be a yr and a half of ready — for a listening to, for a witness, for a reset, for an additional postponement. For wholesome detainees, that is punishment by delay. For the sick, the aged, and the disabled, it’s usually a countdown.

The numbers inform their very own story. In Metro Manila alone, a minimum of 40 detainees die each month, many from preventable sicknesses, resembling tuberculosis, pneumonia, hypertension, and different power situations. These deaths should not attributable to crime; they’re attributable to confinement in areas the place air is scarce, sanitation is insufficient, and medical care is restricted or absent. Detention turns into much less a holding measure and extra a medical threat issue.

The Supreme Court docket has, to its credit score, acknowledged that well being and age matter. Within the landmark choice granting bail to Juan Ponce Enrile, the Court docket acknowledged that frail well being and superior age represent humanitarian grounds for launch. The logic was sound: justice should be tempered with compassion when detention itself turns into merciless.

However therein lies the issue. That compassion has by no means been systematized. There isn’t a clear, uniform mechanism for bizarre detainees — these with out energy, status, or a battalion of legal professionals — to hunt the identical consideration. Humanitarian launch has remained an exception loved by the few, moderately than a proper accessible to all who meet goal standards.

Medical recognizance seeks to right this imbalance, not by decreasing requirements however by clarifying them.

Below the proposed mechanism, a detainee could petition the court docket for launch on medical grounds when three situations are current:

• The detainee suffers from a power, debilitating, or life-threatening sickness.
• Continued detention will irritate the situation or endanger life.
• The jail facility lacks the capability to supply satisfactory remedy.

These should not speculative claims. They should be supported by medical proof.

ALSO ON RAPPLER

The method begins with certification from the jail’s medical officer, detailing the prognosis, the detainee’s situation, the dangers of continued detention, and the ability’s limitations. For critical circumstances, that is adopted by a obligatory unbiased medical analysis by a Division of Well being–accredited doctor or medical panel. This two-tier system protects in opposition to abuse whereas making certain credibility.

The proposal is exact about what constitutes medical urgency. It consists of situations resembling lively tuberculosis, extreme cardiac or respiratory failure, most cancers requiring chemotherapy or palliative care, indicators of organ failure, recurrent hospitalization, fast weight reduction, post-surgical situations requiring rehabilitation, extreme psychological well being issues, and superior age accompanied by comorbidities.

Judicial motion is time-bound. Courts are required to behave on petitions inside 5 judicial days, recognizing that medical emergencies don’t watch for procedural comfort. The place imminent hazard exists, provisional launch could also be ordered pending completion of documentation. Launch could take the type of recognizance, hospital arrest, or home arrest, with situations imposed to make sure continued court docket jurisdiction.

Crucially, medical recognizance doesn’t extinguish felony legal responsibility. The case proceeds. The accused stays beneath the authority of the court docket. Reporting necessities, medical updates, and journey restrictions could also be imposed. Any misrepresentation by the accused or false certification by medical personnel carries penalties, together with revocation of launch and administrative or felony sanctions.

In a system the place roughly 75 % of detainees are awaiting trial, detention usually displays poverty moderately than guilt. Financial bail punishes the indigent and spares the prosperous. Medical recognizance disrupts this logic by shifting the main target from cash to drugs, from means to pay to threat to life.

There’s a deeper query beneath all this: What’s the goal of detention? Whether it is to make sure look in court docket, medical recognizance can obtain that by way of situations. Whether it is to guard public security, releasing a terminally in poor health or severely incapacitated detainee beneath supervision hardly undermines that aim. Whether it is punishment, then we should ask whether or not loss of life by neglect is a sentence our legal guidelines truly authorize.

Medical recognizance doesn’t resolve jail congestion. It doesn’t remedy court docket delay. It doesn’t repair a damaged bail system in a single day. What it does is narrower — and extra pressing. It prevents detention from turning into a type of quiet execution for individuals who are outdated, sick, and nonetheless legally harmless.

A justice system reveals its character not in the way it treats the highly effective, however in the way it treats the powerless. Medical recognizance asks the State to recollect a easy fact: custody doesn’t cancel humanity. And compassion, when structured and accountable, will not be the enemy of justice — it’s its closing proof. – Rappler.com

Raymund E. Narag, PhD, is an affiliate professor in criminology and felony justice on the Faculty of Justice and Public Security, Southern Illinois College, Carbondale.