This text is the results of a collaboration with Josimar. You’ll find Josimar’s corresponding piece right here.
A European tutorial used a false title to signify an opaque Asian-facing bookmaker that’s sponsoring Croatia’s nationwide soccer crew within the run as much as the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
Croatia’s nationwide governing physique of soccer, the Croatian Soccer Federation (HNS), struck the deal to make playing web site Dragon Z6 the crew’s “unique betting companion” throughout Asia in Could 2024.
Promotional footage of the ceremony to ink the two-year settlement was filmed in Zagreb, with Croatian nationwide crew gamers Marco Pašalić, Lovro Majer and Josip Juranović in attendance.
A video posted to Dragon Z6’s web site exhibits HNS Worldwide’s chief government Dennis Lukančić and the federation’s head of promoting Ante Cicvarić signing the contract with the bookmaker’s consultant.
“We maintain Dragon Z6.com in excessive regard,” Cicvarić stated within the clip. “A model with a 25 yr legacy and a stellar status for offering an distinctive gaming expertise. Their motto, ‘Life is a raffle’, resonates deeply with us.”
Dragon Z6’s consultant, who is known as on display screen and in a placard as “Alexander Smith”, described the deal as a “momentous partnership”.
He stated: “The Dragon Z6.com household proudly welcomes the Croatian nationwide soccer crew. We embark on an thrilling journey to grasp our shared ambitions.”
However the man who seems within the footage on behalf of Dragon Z6 just isn’t Alexander Smith. He’s Branko Balon, a senior lecturer in laptop science at Algebra Bernays College in Zagreb.
The Croatian nationwide was recognized utilizing facial recognition search engine PimEyes, with pictures from his Fb, college profile and media experiences confirming the match.
Along with his college place, Balon is the president of non-profit group the Croatian-Chinese language Friendship Society for Cultural, Scientific and Financial Cooperation (CCFS).
He seems to have visited China on a number of events, together with final July when he took half in a visiting scholar programme with the Nishan World Middle of Confucian Research in japanese China’s Shandong province, in accordance with his Fb posts.
Six months earlier than the signing ceremony with HNS, Balon reportedly addressed a Zagreb sports activities and tourism symposium whose attendees included representatives from the Croatian Soccer Federation.
After initially confirming receipt of an electronic mail from Bellingcat, Branko Balon didn’t reply to questions. Dragon Z6 didn’t reply to a number of emails.
Dennis Lukančić stated the Croatia Soccer Federation revered the foundations and rules of the game’s governing our bodies in addition to Croatian regulation, however didn’t reply particular questions on the way it grew to become concerned with Dragon Z6 or if it was beforehand conscious of Balon’s actual identification.
“Concerning the signing ceremony, we be aware that the Croatian Soccer Federation didn’t publish or formally talk the identification of the Dragon Z6 consultant current on the occasion,” he stated. “As is customary with such ceremonies, the occasion itself was of a promotional nature and didn’t represent the formal execution of contractual documentation.”
“The Croatian Soccer Federation just isn’t able to touch upon the interior selections, communications, or presentation selections of Dragon Z6, together with the usage of names or identities in their very own supplies or appearances. Any questions concerning the identification or illustration of Dragon Z6 at promotional occasions are greatest addressed to Dragon Z6 or their representatives.
“In any of our proceedings we at all times negotiate in good religion and we respect all rights and obligations that come up from any settlement.”
Lukančić stated the federation had carried out “normal compliance and due diligence procedures” earlier than getting into the deal and that the settlement was executed between the related authorized entities, with Dragon Z6 “represented by their duly authorised signatories”.
Requested which nation Dragon Z6 was headquartered in, who its helpful proprietor was, and for the title of the one that signed the contract on behalf of the playing firm, Lukančić stated: “In our earlier electronic mail we gave you already all solutions and our place on this matter.”
We additionally requested if the Dragon Z6 deal contains sponsorship through the upcoming FIFA World Cup, however didn’t obtain a response. England is Croatia’s first opponent, going through off in opposition to the Three Lions in Dallas on June 17.
The Many-Headed Dragon
Open supply findings counsel that Dragon Z6 – generally referred to in Chinese language as “Zunlong Kaisheng” – is simply the newest iteration of an Asian-facing on-line playing platform that has been sponsoring Western sports activities groups below completely different names for greater than a decade. Dragon Z6 seems to be related to the Hong Kong-linked playing firm KashBet, also referred to as KB88.
Playing doesn’t happen immediately on the Z6.com area. The positioning is actually a gateway that redirects customers to a fluctuating variety of mirror web sites with alphanumeric string domains. These Chinese language-language websites host the playing content material, together with live-streamed card video games, and supply clues about Dragon Z6’s affiliation with KashBet.
The picture of Dutch former skilled footballer Robin van Persie is featured prominently on Dragon Z6’s mirror websites. Within the “About” part of those web sites, the web on line casino says it signed van Persie as its model ambassador in 2021. The identical {photograph} of him is used interchangeably to advertise each Dragon Z6 and the KashBet model.
Van Persie’s agent, Kees Vos, stated the footballer had not entered right into a partnership with Kashbet, was not concerned with Dragon Z6, and had not been conscious that his picture was getting used on these web sites.
“We’ve got taken discover of the abuse of the picture of our shopper Robin van Persie by a number of Asian playing platforms, and we are going to instruct our attorneys to take authorized motion in opposition to these events,” Vos stated.
Z6’s mirror websites additionally say Zunlong Kaisheng is the “official sponsor” of Bundesliga golf equipment Bayer Leverkusen and Augsburg, Brazilian facet Fluminense, Italian membership Roma, English league crew Wigan Athletic and Dutch membership Ajax.
Nonetheless, it was KashBet that signed sponsorship offers with these soccer groups in 2017 and 2019. No file of a sponsorship with FC Augsburg was discovered, however KB88 was promoted in pitchside promoting throughout one of many crew’s 2019 house video games.
In 2019, Australian soccer crew Melbourne Victory dropped their AFC Champions League sponsor “Kaishi Leisure” after issues have been raised concerning the firm’s hyperlink to Kashbet.
KashBet’s consultant on the signing with Bayer Leverkusen was the identical one that represented Kaishi Leisure through the Melbourne Victory announcement in the identical yr.
A YouTube channel branded as “Zunlong Kaisheng” and that includes the Dragon Z6 brand hosts a 2024 video titled “Welcome to Dragon On line casino”. It exhibits a tour of a facility the place feminine croupiers are live-streamed working desk video games.
The video additionally options framed images purporting to point out numerous ceremonies. These embody the KashBet picture of van Persie, in addition to membership groups AS Roma and AFC Ajax’s Asian betting partnerships with KB88 in 2017. One other photograph claims to point out former Actual Madrid, Chelsea and Belgium footballer Eden Hazard turning into a Dragon On line casino “model ambassador” in 2020.
Bellingcat’s emails to representatives for Eden Hazard, who was not too long ago introduced as a “world ambassador” for on-line playing platform Stake, weren’t returned.
The situation of the ability just isn’t acknowledged however open supply proof exhibits it was filmed within the Philippines, the place offshore gaming operators have been banned in 2024. Reverse picture searches affirm one part of the promotional video was shot within the five-star Peninsula Resort in Makati Metropolis, Manila.
Offshore Company Labyrinth
Dutch membership Ajax, who have been sponsored by KB88 in 2017, stated their deal concerned Hong Kong agency KB88 Leisure Tradition Restricted. An organization primarily based within the British Virgin Islands can be behind commerce names linked to KB88, in accordance with a 2023 investigation by Dutch outlet NRC. However the entities purportedly answerable for the playing platform don’t cease there.
Dragon Z6’s web site hyperlinks to a 2012 assertion posted by English Championship membership, Queen’s Park Rangers (QPR), asserting a one yr deal to make KashBet the membership’s worldwide betting companion. The press launch, which was faraway from QPR’s web site earlier this yr, stated KashBet was “absolutely owned and operated by Eager Ocean Leisure (IOM) Restricted” and licensed and controlled by the Playing Supervision Fee (GSC) on the Isle of Man.
Information from the Isle of Man firm registry present an organization named Goldenway Investments (UK) Restricted was integrated in 2010 and altered its title to Eager Ocean Leisure (IOM) Restricted a month later. The corporate’s two administrators have been all residents of the Isle of Man, including Hong Kong resident Yong Tang because the third director in November of that yr. An organization appearing because the secretary, Rivercroft Restricted, can be named in paperwork.
An archive of the Isle of Man’s Playing Supervision Fee’s 2012-13 annual report exhibits that Eager Ocean Leisure obtained a full on-line playing license. This enabled it to enter into the QPR deal because the regulated physique behind Kashbet.
Filings on the Isle of Man register are low on element. Stability sheets usually are not filed, and the one documented exercise concerning the firm was the occasional motion of Isle of Man-based administrators. By November 2015, Yong Tang was the only real director of the corporate.
In 2016, Eager Ocean Leisure was knowledgeable by the Corporations Registry that it didn’t have the authority to keep up its registered workplace on the deal with it had given as its premises. Yong Tang didn’t reply to this correspondence, in accordance with the accessible paperwork, and the corporate was subsequently struck off the register.
Gaming Compliance Worldwide (GCI), a regulatory intelligence agency that displays the worldwide on-line playing market, stated Dragon Z6 and KashBet didn’t have a present gaming license in any credible jurisdiction.
Ismail Vali, GCI president and the founder and former chief government of Yield Sec, which tracks playing and streaming marketplaces, stated Dragon Z6 “ruthlessly” focused audiences in China – the place playing is illegitimate – however that didn’t imply the operators have been primarily based there.
“Usually, within the unlawful playing mannequin, they use triangulation and separation,” he stated. “It’s essentially the most primary type of organised crime: function your enterprise in a single place, incorporate your enterprise in one other, make your cash from many locations, financial institution your cash in lots of locations, and, lastly, make investments and spend it in all places to create extra crime. Separating the weather of the criminality creates issues for tracing, policing and enforcement.”
Vali stated Western soccer associations which can be struggling to function on shrinking budgets might be lured into sponsorship offers with unregulated and unlawful playing corporations, which have been centered on constructing model recognition by live-broadcast video games.
“The unlawful playing corporations aren’t centered upon creating wealth from the direct viewers of the golf equipment or from the soccer affiliation’s footprint in Croatia,” he stated. “What they’re creating wealth from is the viewers the soccer matches are broadcast to globally. They need to talk what the model is and since it’s related to worldwide soccer individuals suppose it should be reliable.
“The entire level right here is to recruit you thru sports activities. That’s the most cost effective method to get you since you need to place a wager on Croatia versus the Czech Republic within the World Cup qualifiers. As soon as they recruit a buyer cheaply by way of sports activities occasions, they’ll then cross-sell or migrate them into on line casino and extra merchandise – the place the revenue margin is way larger.
“Unregulated playing corporations need a blended buyer – they don’t simply need you for sports activities betting, they need you for every little thing.”
Ross Higgins and Connor Plunkett contributed to this text.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the power to hold out our work relies on the sort help of particular person donors. If you need to help our work, you are able to do so right here. It’s also possible to subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our Publication and comply with us on Bluesky right here, Instagram right here, Reddit right here and YouTube right here.
