Warning: Consists of graphic descriptions of animal hurt and pictures of animal elements from the outset.
A Bellingcat investigation has uncovered a Myanmar-based wildlife trafficker who has operated brazenly throughout social media for at the very least six years, claiming to have offered tiger bones, rhino horn, elephant pores and skin and different merchandise from protected and endangered species to prospects in Myanmar, China and Thailand.
By analysing a whole lot of adverts and buyer conversations, Bellingcat traced greater than US$21,000 in gross sales, recognized cross-border shipments linked to a number of cost accounts, and geolocated the seller’s house deal with. The vendor regularly used graphic pictures to persuade consumers that his wildlife merchandise had been real, sharing footage of animals earlier than and after they had been killed as proof of authenticity.
Following this investigation, Meta eliminated 10 Fb accounts, WeChat suspended three accounts and revoked their cost features, TikTok and YouTube every eliminated one account, and authorities in Myanmar and Thailand stated they might study the findings additional.
On December 21 2022, a Fb account shared a reel of a tiger cub mendacity unconscious beneath the caption: “Time for winemaking”, adopted by a number of laughing face emojis. 4 days later, the identical account shared one other reel, this time of an grownup tiger mendacity immobile on an orange plastic sheet as a person approaches with a knife.
Two separate movies posted to Fb by the account referred to as MB.
The account behind each movies belongs to Mei Ba (hereafter MB), a self-described Conventional Chinese language Medication (TCM) physician based mostly in Myanmar. In TCM, vegetation and animal merchandise are used to arrange treatments based mostly on established medicinal formulation. These treatments can take many kinds, together with natural teas, simmered concoctions, elements steeped in wine, and capsules. TCM can be typically related to pseudoscientific beliefs, reminiscent of the concept consuming an animal’s organ can nourish the corresponding organ within the human physique.
A Bellingcat investigation has discovered that MB regularly advertises the trafficked elements of critically endangered and susceptible species to prospects in Myanmar, Thailand and China. An evaluation of social media posts revealed by MB over six years discovered references to gross sales involving elements of bears, elephants, leopards, musk deer, otters, pangolins, rhinos, seahorses and tigers, all of that are protected species.
Benefiting from Protected Species
For at the very least six years, MB has used ten completely different Fb accounts below variations of his identify to promote animal elements and merchandise on the market, together with these derived from susceptible and guarded species.
MB has marketed tiger physique elements and merchandise, together with skins and wine comprised of bones. Myanmar’s wild tiger inhabitants was final estimated at a minimal of twenty-two animals (in a 2019 examine revealed earlier than the civil struggle). Licensed tiger farms, described as being much like zoos, additionally function within the nation. Nonetheless, Myanmar legislation prohibits the killing of any tiger, wild or captive.
Bellingcat has additionally recognized adverts providing leopard physique elements, together with pores and skin, bones and gallbladders, in addition to a product described as a “whip”, a euphemism for a penis. Lots of the adverts explicitly acknowledged that the physique elements got here from wild animals. The Indochinese leopard is classed as critically endangered, with fewer than 800 mature people believed to stay within the wild throughout mainland South-East Asia.
MB has marketed physique elements and different merchandise derived from Asian elephants, an endangered species, together with pores and skin offered in items and powdered kind, in addition to their genitals.
Certainly one of MB’s extra graphic posts confirmed a not too long ago killed and butchered moon bear – a kind of Asian black bear which is classed as a susceptible species. MB has additionally marketed varied bear physique elements on the market, together with paws, heads, gallbladders, bile and fats.
Entire rhino horns, in addition to bracelets and medicinal merchandise comprised of rhino horn, have been marketed by MB. Though rhinos have been extinct in Myanmar because the Eighties, the nation stays a recognized transit route for rhino merchandise transferring from India to China and elsewhere in South-East Asia, suggesting the gadgets marketed by MB originated outdoors Myanmar.
Rhino merchandise as marketed by MB on Fb. Labels added by Bellingcat.
Beneath Myanmar legislation, anybody convicted of killing, possessing or buying and selling a “fully protected species,” or its elements, faces a minimal jail sentence of three years and a nice below a conservation legislation launched in 2018. Fully protected species marketed by MB embody Asiatic black bears, elephants, leopards and rhinos.
Bellingcat contacted a number of Myanmar authorities authorities for remark relating to MB’s wildlife commerce. The Myanmar embassy in London confirmed receipt of Bellingcat’s request and stated it might seek the advice of the related authorities in Myanmar.
Convincing Clients
Counterfeits are widespread within the unlawful wildlife commerce. Buffalo horn is usually carved to resemble rhino horn, whereas cattle penises are handed off as tiger elements. A lot of MB’s promotional technique subsequently focuses on persuading consumers that his merchandise are real.
To market rhino horn, MB has posted pictures of the gadgets on scales or held up in opposition to a light-weight, which he claims demonstrates the feel of real horn. For tiger bones, in a single publish he stated {that a} patch of pores and skin could be left connected to show their authenticity.
MB has additionally posted movies of current leopard and tiger kills. He has shared footage of stay tigers in cages adopted by pictures of the identical animals being butchered for his or her skins, bones, skulls, claws and fangs.
Bellingcat solely analysed open supply proof, together with social posts, buyer conversations, seen transactions and transport receipts. Subsequently, the authenticity and composition of the wildlife merchandise marketed or offered couldn’t be independently verified.
However, given the quantity and graphic nature of those posts, MB’s skill to function on Fb for at the very least six years raises questions on why his accounts remained energetic up till Bellingcat contacted Meta.
Evading Platform Moderation
For years, MB has brazenly marketed his enterprise on Fb, posting a whole lot of adverts throughout ten profiles and varied teams. He typically makes use of coded language, together with Chinese language-language euphemisms in his feedback.
For instance, he makes use of “eraser” (橡皮) to check with “elephant pores and skin” (象皮), a Mandarin homophone with characters which are additionally visually related, proven beneath.
MB additionally makes use of pinyin, the phonetic system for spelling Mandarin Chinese language phrases utilizing Latin letters. For instance, in a single publish, he abbreviates the pinyin phrase for “rhino” (xīniú) as “X”, promoting “X horn powder”, and makes use of “Y” (pinyin: yào) as shorthand for “medication”. He additionally regularly makes use of animal emojis, together with tiger, elephant, rhino, deer and bear, to check with merchandise derived from these animals with out naming them immediately.
Requested why MB had been in a position to function for thus lengthy with out being banned and the way it detects widespread evasion ways reminiscent of coded language, Meta responded: “Unhealthy actors continuously evolve their ways to keep away from enforcement, which is why we companion with teams and spend money on instruments and expertise to detect and take away violating content material.”
Cross-Border Commerce
To map the size of MB’s enterprise, Bellingcat analysed greater than 500 screenshots of buyer conversations spanning Might 2021 to Might 2026. Initially happening on Fb, Viber and WeChat, these exchanges had been later reposted by MB on Fb.
Typically blurred or cropped, the fabric seems to have been shared as a part of a method to current MB as a trusted vendor who reliably delivers to prospects. Nonetheless, given the content material regularly included transport labels with names and addresses, product descriptions, and worth discussions, Bellingcat was in a position to hint a part of MB’s buyer base and earnings. Notably, solely content material MB selected to repost was obtainable for evaluation, which means the findings signify solely a pattern of his general exercise.
Throughout the dataset, Bellingcat recognized greater than 150 transactions totalling US$21,000. The United Nations estimated Myanmar’s annual per capita earnings at between $300 and $430 in 2023.
Bellingcat evaluation of MB’s digital footprint displaying income earned per species by MB. Foreign money in US$. Commerce values are estimated based mostly on yearly common black market trade charges.
Primarily based on supply information, Bellingcat recognized 119 deliveries inside Myanmar, 27 to mainland China, and 9 to Thailand. Inside Myanmar, shipments had been most frequently despatched to shared pickup factors in cities or cities, whereas these to China had been extra regularly despatched on to particular person addresses.
Shipments inside Myanmar most frequently concerned small portions of powders or medicines, reminiscent of 3 to 7 g of rhino horn powder or 5 g of bear gall bladder. In contrast, deliveries to China extra typically included complete animal elements reminiscent of rhino horn or tiger bones, or bigger portions of merchandise, together with 500 g to 1 kg of elephant pores and skin powder or 10 to 40 bottles of drugs.
MB’s highest-value recorded transaction was to a buyer in Yiyang, Hunan Province, China and concerned two tiger femur bones weighing simply over 2.5 kg. Offered in July 2022, the bones fetched 23,500 Chinese language Yuan (US$3,494). The client was requested to supply a screenshot as proof of cost. MB later reposted this on Fb, alongside {a photograph} of the bones wrapped in cling movie and a transport label for Deppon Logistics connected.
Bellingcat contacted Deppon Logistics for remark, sharing the picture and monitoring quantity proven beneath, however obtained no response on the time of publication.
Beneath Chinese language legislation, shopping for, transporting, or promoting protected or endangered species can, in probably the most severe circumstances, carry jail sentences of greater than 10 years. Asian elephants and wild tigers are listed as “Class 1” protected animals. A allow system does exist for using captive-bred tigers, though it stays controversial.
Beneath the Conference on Worldwide Commerce in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) Appendix I, worldwide commerce in any endangered species, together with Asian elephants and tigers, in addition to their derivatives reminiscent of pores and skin powder, scales and bones, is prohibited. China, Myanmar and Thailand are all events to the treaty.
Bellingcat contacted the Common Administration of Customs of China for touch upon MB’s wildlife gross sales to China however didn’t obtain a response on the time of publication.
Bellingcat additionally discovered proof of 9 deliveries to Thailand, together with a tiger penis and a number of other TCM powders stated to comprise canine, yak and seahorse, all species regulated by Thai legislation and guarded below CITES.
The Thai Pure Sources and Environmental Crime Division advised Bellingcat that it already screens packages falsely declared as conventional medication however discovered to comprise protected wildlife elements or elements derived from them. Following Bellingcat’s findings on MB’s actions, the division stated it might examine additional.
A big proportion of MB’s exports to all three international locations had been bottles of TCM powders or tablets. For instance, a “kidney replenishing medication” was presupposed to comprise deer, canine, gecko, praying mantis, seahorse and yak, whereas a “prostate medication” was stated to incorporate deer, seahorse and canine.
Beneath Chinese language legislation, all packaged TCMs should carry labels clearly displaying the producer’s identify, full ingredient listing, manufacturing and expiry dates, and knowledge on negative effects and security. None of those particulars had been current on MB’s labels.
A number of banks accounts
Over six years of reposted conversations with prospects, Bellingcat noticed MB requesting funds to at the very least 15 completely different accounts, together with seven through WeChat Pay, two through Alipay and 6 through third-party financial institution accounts, which MB described as belonging to pals or household.
For instance, in Might 2022, a buyer bought 1kg of elephant pores and skin powder to be shipped to Chiuchow, Guangdong Province, China. MB advised the client his WeChat account couldn’t presently obtain the cost and instructed them to ship the funds to his “sis” [female associate], proven beneath.
Each WeChat Pay and Alipay’s phrases and situations prohibit using their companies to obtain funds for unlawful actions.
After being contacted by Bellingcat, WeChat suspended three accounts, revoking all cost features and eradicating related content material.
Alipay didn’t reply to Bellingcat’s request for remark.
Figuring out MB
MB’s brazen on-line actions embody working at the very least ten Fb profiles, two TikTok accounts, one WeChat account and one YouTube channel. He’s the only administrator of a Fb group with almost 1,000 members. Throughout these platforms, he has amassed some 12,000 followers.
Whereas utilizing variations of “Mei Ba” (MB) throughout most of those accounts, he additionally makes use of the Chinese language identify “Mei Xiangfu” on his private WeChat account. The identify “Might Kyin Phu” additionally seems alongside cost QR codes when prospects are requested to switch funds. Beneath is a QR code for Myanmar’s largest financial institution, KBZ, which incorporates what seems to be MB’s authorized identify: U Might Kyin Phu, with “U” used as an honorific equal to Mr.
Since 2019, MB has used the identical ID photograph as his profile image throughout a number of platforms, in addition to his marriage ceremony photograph as his TikTok profile image and Fb banner picture. His spouse, recognized within the marriage ceremony photograph and in different pictures posted by MB, has additionally been discovered promoting susceptible and guarded species through her Fb account.
With greater than 3,100 followers, she regularly reposts MB’s adverts whereas additionally sharing screenshots of conversations with prospects. For instance, in a single WeChat trade later reposted to Fb, she discusses the money sale of 5 “actual” tiger penises.
From MB’s posts, Bellingcat geolocated a home in Lashio, japanese Myanmar, used to {photograph} animal elements on the market in his commercials. MB has posted content material from this property since 2020.
Within the pictures beneath, what MB describes as “leopard gallbladders” could be seen hanging from a balcony, revealing the format of the property’s yard and the rooftops of adjoining buildings. Though Lashio shouldn’t be lined by Road View, the distinctive roof seen in MB’s pictures matched with user-uploaded images on Google Maps.
Bellingcat contacted each MB and his spouse for touch upon the findings of this report. Each had been reached through WeChat and seem to have obtained the request, however didn’t reply on the time of publication.
Information visuals by Galen Reich, Graphics by Merel Zoet, Editor, Claire Press.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the flexibility to hold out our work relies on the sort help of particular person donors. If you want to help our work, you are able to do so right here. You can too subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our E-newsletter and observe us on Bluesky right here, Instagram right here, Reddit right here and YouTube right here.
