The 2 federal immigration brokers who fired on Minneapolis protester Alex Pretti are recognized in authorities data as Border Patrol agent Jesus Ochoa and Customs and Border Safety officer Raymundo Gutierrez.
The data seen by ProPublica record Ochoa, 43, and Gutierrez, 35, because the shooters throughout the lethal encounter final weekend that left Pretti lifeless and ignited large protests and requires legal investigations.
Each males had been assigned to Operation Metro Surge, an immigration enforcement dragnet launched in December that despatched scores of armed and masked brokers throughout the town.
CBP, which employs each males, has up to now refused to launch their names and has disclosed few different details concerning the lethal incident, which got here days after a distinct immigration agent shot and killed one other Minneapolis protester, a 37-year-old mom of three named Renee Good.
Pretti’s killing, and the next secrecy surrounding the brokers concerned, comes because the nation confronts the results of President Donald Trump’s aggressive immigration crackdown. The sweeps in cities throughout the nation have been marked by scenes of violence, towards immigrants and U.S. residents, by brokers allowed to cover their identities with masks — an nearly exceptional apply in regulation enforcement. In consequence, the general public has been saved from one of many chief methods it has to carry officers concerned in such altercations accountable: their id.
Each Democratic and Republican lawmakers have known as for a clear investigation into the killing of Pretti, a 37-year-old intensive care unit nurse working at a Division of Veterans Affairs hospital.
“We will need to have a clear, unbiased investigation into the Minnesota taking pictures, and people accountable—irrespective of their title—have to be held accountable,” Republican Sen. John Curtis of Utah wrote on X on Monday.
The company despatched a discover to some members of Congress on Tuesday acknowledging that two brokers fired Glock pistols throughout the altercation that left Pretti lifeless. That discover doesn’t embody the brokers’ names. A spokesperson for the Division of Homeland Safety, which oversees CBP, mentioned the brokers had been positioned on depart after the Jan. 24 taking pictures. And after every week of protests and calls from lawmakers for a evaluation, the Justice Division mentioned Friday that its Civil Rights Division is investigating the taking pictures. A DOJ spokesperson didn’t reply questions, together with whether or not DHS has shared supplies, equivalent to body-camera footage, with its investigators.
Ochoa is a Border Patrol agent who joined CBP in 2018. Gutierrez joined in 2014 and works for CBP’s Workplace of Area Operations. He’s assigned to a particular response group, which conducts high-risk operations like these of police SWAT items. Data present each males are from South Texas.
Within the aftermath of the taking pictures, Gregory Bovino, who has orchestrated high-intensity immigration sweeps and arrests in a string of Democratic-led cities since early 2025, was faraway from his function as Border Patrol commander at massive and reassigned to his former publish in El Centro, California.
A spokesperson for DHS declined to reply questions concerning the two brokers and referred ProPublica to the FBI. The FBI declined to remark. ProPublica made a number of makes an attempt to name Ochoa and Gutierrez however neither answered.
Ochoa, who goes by Jesse, graduated from the College of Texas-Pan American with a level in legal justice, in response to his ex-wife, Angelica Ochoa. A longtime resident of the Rio Grande Valley, Ochoa had for years dreamed of working for the Border Patrol and eventually landed a job there, she mentioned. By the point the couple break up in 2021, he had turn out to be a gun fanatic with about 25 rifles, pistols and shotguns, Angelica Ochoa mentioned.
DHS’ disclosure to Congress was drawn from an inside evaluation of the brokers’ body-camera footage, which has not been launched to the general public. State investigators, in the meantime, have accused their federal counterparts of blocking them from investigating the taking pictures.
“We don’t have any data on the shooters,” a Minneapolis metropolis spokesperson mentioned. A spokesperson for Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz mentioned Tuesday that his workplace additionally had “not been given the names, and we don’t have any new data on the investigation.”
Democrats on the Home Judiciary Committee, in a letter to Legal professional Common Pam Bondi Monday, accused the Justice Division of overlaying up proof in each Pretti’s and Good’s killings.
“DOJ has additionally blocked prosecutors and brokers from cooperating with state regulation enforcement officers and prevented state officers from accessing proof,” the letter mentioned.
Maryland Rep. Jamie Raskin, the highest Democrat on the Home Judiciary Committee, informed CNN on Sunday that immigration brokers shouldn’t be masked.
“They shouldn’t be nameless. They need to be identifiable. And so they should have guidelines of engagement that don’t permit them to terrorize and intimidate, harass and assault U.S. residents and different folks,” he mentioned.
The discover to Congress mentioned that the taking pictures occurred when Pretti resisted arrest after officers had been unable to get him and a feminine protester out of the road.
The CBP officer “tried to maneuver the lady and Pretti out of the roadway. The lady and Pretti didn’t transfer,” the report reads. “CBP personnel tried to take Pretti into custody. Pretti resisted CBP personnel’s efforts and a battle ensued.”
In accordance with the report, one agent then yelled “He’s obtained a gun!” a number of instances, and two others “discharged” their Glock pistols.
In movies broadly shared on-line, Pretti could be seen holding up a cellphone, documenting the actions of federal brokers and officers as they roamed the streets of a preferred meals and humanities district. In accordance with information reviews, Pretti was involved concerning the more and more unstable siege of the town by federal brokers.
Within the movies, a masked agent seems to knock a lady to the bottom. Pretti involves her support, getting between them, at which level the officer deploys pepper spray at his face. Two brokers then seize Pretti and pull him to the bottom, whereas extra federal personnel pile on. Throughout the battle, the brokers unleash a collection of photographs — roughly 10 — as onlookers scream.
Pretti was armed on the time of the encounter with a legally owned handgun, in response to state and federal officers. Some analyses of bystander video seem to point out a federal agent taking Pretti’s gun from his hip earlier than the primary photographs had been fired. The brokers’ masks and the chaos of the altercation make it troublesome to distinguish one from one other.
These movies seem to contradict the claims by Bovino and different officers, together with DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, that Pretti had come to assault brokers.
“The brokers tried to disarm the person, however he violently resisted,” Bovino mentioned in a Jan. 25 information convention. “Fearing for his life and the lives and security of fellow officers, a Border Patrol agent fired defensive photographs.”
Within the preliminary aftermath, Stephen Miller, a high Trump aide and a number one drive behind the immigration enforcement operations, known as Pretti “a would-be murderer.” However Miller modified tack later within the week when he mentioned in a press release that CBP officers “could not have been following” protocol associated to confronting bystanders.
Further video has surfaced exhibiting Pretti in one other altercation with federal brokers 11 days earlier than he was killed. The video reveals Pretti yelling on the brokers, who get in an SUV and begin to drive away. Pretti then kicks out the taillight of the automobile and the brokers, who wore protecting masks, soar out and sort out him to the bottom.
It’s unclear if any of the identical brokers had been concerned in each incidents.
Lauren Bonds, govt director of the Nationwide Police Accountability Challenge, mentioned that many native and state police departments are “far more clear” than CBP when officers shoot folks. “Increasingly police departments are selecting to launch bodycam footage or dashcam footage inside a few days.”
Gil Kerlikowske, a former CBP commissioner, informed ProPublica that it’s troublesome to attract conclusions from the chaos in bystander movies. Nonetheless, he mentioned, the taking pictures might need been prevented. Pretti’s try to assist the lady knocked to the bottom might have been seen as interfering with federal regulation enforcement, he mentioned. However the resolution by the officers to right away use pepper spray created a chaotic scene that seemingly contributed to Pretti’s loss of life.
“The opposite agent might have mentioned ‘don’t intrude’ or ‘stand again,’” Kerlikowske mentioned. “Somewhat than transfer instantly to pepper spray, you’ll be able to arrest the individual.” It’s a part of a sample, he mentioned, of federal officers leaping straight to make use of of drive in conditions that might have been de-escalated however as a substitute create hazard for each brokers and their targets.
Pretti’s loss of life, and the federal authorities’s characterization of the occasion, sparked speedy protests, spurring hundreds of individuals to exit into frigid circumstances in Minneapolis and different American cities. The taking pictures has additionally drawn intense criticism from political leaders, together with Walz, who has promised his state’s regulation enforcement will conduct its personal legal investigation.
